Social Emotional Lying

“Well firstly, I don’t really want to get put into like a psych ward,” said sophomore Grace Anderson while reflecting on her SEL survey answers. “If you are honest on that survey,” she said, “your counselor tells your parents or the school or whatever, and they take it to the extreme.”

The Panorama survey has eight categories: “Supportive Relationships, Self-Management, Social Awareness, Perseverance, Growth Mindset, Emotion Regulation, Sense of Belonging, and Self-Efficacy.” According to Vice Principal Nicole Heinlein, the survey’s purpose is to “make our school a better place for students” by telling its administrators “what the students think.”

The data from each of these sections “lets us know areas where we are doing well as a school and areas that we need to improve,” said Heinlein.

Heinlein says that “the survey results help drive professional development for teachers, topics we focus on in Po‘okela, and assemblies we might schedule for the year.” The Hawai’i Department of Education has been giving student perception surveys since 2011, but the Lahainaluna Panorama survey has been used at Lahainaluna since the 2019-2020 school year.

Misidentifications

While the survey is meant to reflect student perceptions, Mia Lee complains that it distorts her feelings. “I’m not depressed,” she said, “but like those questions make it look like I am.” “You either look like you are a robot and have no feelings or you’re depressed. I personally feel like there is no in between.”

Sophomore Jaeyln Galasinao thinks that these distortions are to be expected. “They’re high school students; I do not think they’re gonna answer them truthfully.” She is sure that “no one tells the truth on them. Most of the time they just quickly click through it because they want to get it done with and move onto whatever they’re working on in Po‘okela or whatever.”

Freshman Eli Hegrenes thinks the survey falls short in other ways. “[The questions] don’t relate to students’ actual life at school,” he said, “most of the questions don’t even apply to that student.” Eli suggests that “if there was diversity in the questions depending on how the students answered them, then students could feel more compelled to answer them truthfully.”

“I think some of them are good because they do reflect, like, me, but some of them are, like, actually stupid,” says Lee. “Do you think people at your school understand you?” she said, mocking one of the questions.

Faking Happy

“Everyone’s just answering to make the school look better,” said sophomore Kaliyah Cutty, who worries about getting “called into the counselors or something like that because my answers on a survey.”

“We see trends,” says head counselor Darcie Webber. “We see information that, you know, would help us, ostensibly, to be able to support kids that have a need for support, not individual names.” Asked about bringing flagged kids in for questioning, “I’m not gonna say that we can’t,” Webber said, “but I don’t know that we can. So I never have.”

“I think where the confusion might be coming in is that last year, after the fire, the state came in with some other kind of survey,” Webber said. “Those children were brought in for individual counseling sessions, or at least interviews because they were flagged as children that needed immediate attention and support.” “There is the possibility, rather, that there are kids who went through that experience and conflated that SOS training and survey with the SEL survey.”

Results from the spring 2024 SEL survey report that 35 percent of students agreed with the statement that they belong somewhat at the school and 8 percent of students said they feel like they belong a little bit. This data could suggest that a significant number of students don’t feel connected to other students at our school or that they don’t feel accepted.

It can also suggest that our school is doing something good because more students than not have a positive sense of belonging. Yet, student opinions on the data could be the result of students clicking random answers to get the survey done and avoid a visit to counselors.

Galasinao says she just wants “to get it over with. I have stuff to do and that’s just an extra burden.” She says that Po‘okela “helps because it’s right after one of my most stressful, heaviest work-loaded classes.”

Nothing Changes

Students like junior Cora Gruber have taken the option to opt out of the survey, explaining that “my mom doesn’t want me to do it because she thinks it’s a waste of time.” Cora says that her mom “would rather have me do school work and something more valuable like learning.” She thinks it is isn't valuable because “what I say doesn’t matter and the school doesn’t change anything.”

Senior Zhi Clark states, “I don’t think they’re really effective. I don’t really see a lot of change happen, like socially.”

The only growth in the survey results was “sense of belonging,” up 1 percentage point from 41 percent in winter of 2024. Clark feels that “at the end of the day, no matter how I say I feel about teachers, nothing really changes.”